Five Pennies Creamery Menu
Welcome to Five Pennies Creamery, a charming ice cream haven located at 288 Main St, Beacon, NY. This delightful spot boasts an impressive array of flavors, crafted fresh daily, ensuring each scoop delivers creamy perfection. With options for a small indulgence at $5.52 or a larger experience at $7.67, guests can customize their treats with a selection of up to 13 flavors.
Highlights include the indulgent Banana Split, the nostalgic Malted Milkshake, and the delightful Ice Cream Flight, perfect for flavor adventurers. Patrons rave about the rich textures and just-right sweetness, with local favorites like Boston Cream and Cake Batter often mentioned.
Five Pennies also accommodates various dietary preferences, featuring vegan options, and offers a cozy atmosphere with ample seating. Whether you're after a quick scoop or a family outing, this creamery invites everyone to savor the joy of ice cream in a welcoming setting.
Scoops
Small Scoop 1 Flavor
Ice cream of choice in cup select 1 flavor
Large Scoop 13 Flavors
Ice cream of choice in cup select 13 flavors
Medium Scoop 12 Flavors
Ice cream of choice in cup select 12 flavors
Malted Milkshake 12 Flavors
Blended ice cream with milk and malted milk powder select 12 flavors
Banana Split 13 Flavors
Fresh banana with three scoops of ice cream, 3 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry select 13 flavors and 13 toppings
Pint 12 Flavors
Handpacked pint of ice cream select 12 flavors
Ice Cream Flight 4 Flavors
Selection of 4 mini ice creams select 4 flavors
Milkshake 12 Flavors
Blended ice cream with milk select 12 flavors
Specialty Items
Extras Sides
Waffle Cone
Topping Side Cup
Wafer Cone
Sugar Cone
Small Sundae 1 Flavor
Ice cream of choice, 2 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry select 1 flavor and 2 toppings
Medium Sundae 12 Flavors
Ice cream of choice, 2 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry select 12 flavors and 2 toppings
Large Sundae 13 Flavors
Ice cream of choice, 2 toppings, and whipped cream and cherry select 13 flavors and 2 toppings
